Friday, February 16, 2007

Islamaphobia is the methodological offspring of Anti-Semitism

In honor of the Daniel Pipes motivated hacking of Imam 'Abdul-Alim Musa's Myspace page I present the following reflection.

Both antisemitism and Islamophobia involve rifling through a diverse array of religious and cultural texts with the aim of extracting those statements which would cast the target in the worst possible light. Both presume to dictate to the Jew or to the Muslim what kind of person they ought to be; the fall back position for both the Islamaphobe or the Antisemite when confronted with Jews or Muslims who fail to typify a stereotype is to claim that these Jews or Muslims are not being true to their own beliefs, are inauthentic, self-hating, etc. Both the Islamaphobe and the anti-semite elevate text over context; they extract the lines they need with no concern for either the surrounding material or the larger tradition in which the text is embedded. The Islamaphobe takes Ayahs of the Quran which counsel against relying on non-muslims for protection and uses them to convict Muslims of intractable otherness and relentless hostility. Likewise, the Antisemite takes theoretical discussions in the Talmud about the proper relations between Jews and Gentiles and uses them to construct a slanderous stereotype of the Jew as petty tribalist, with no moral concern for those not part of his or her tiny nation. Both ignore the rich history of interaction between both communities and the outside world and both omit the underlying universalistic ethical stance of the two communities. It is inconsistent to abhor and excoriate one without taking a similar stance against the other.

Labels:

Tuesday, February 06, 2007

Thoughts on the Conference on Islamic Law in the West

On Friday and Saturday I attended a conference on Islamic Law and the West held at the Washington College of Law. The list of speakers included Dr.Umar Faruq Abdullah, Dr. Mohammad Fadel, and Dr. M. Shahid Alam. The introductory panel consisted of an interesting, if basic, introduction to the categories used in Islamic Law (Dr. Fadel), an analysis of Islamic Constitutionalism with reference to the ideas of Abdul-Karim Sourush (Intisar Rabb), and an account of the recent attempt to provide alternative, religiously based arbitration in Ontario (Jasmin Zine). Dr. Abdullah presented the keynote address on "Muslims in the Mainstream" where he recounted something of the history of Islam in America and suggested tipping points to increase our political capital and counteract mainstream media demonization of Islam and Muslims.

The next day saw a panel on Islam and Violence. I was captivated by the speech of Dr. Alam; he spoke a truth which needed to be proclaimed in an elite college like American University. His primary thesis was that the threat of terror has been greatly exaggerated in order to scare the American people into agreement with draconian government policies and to manipulate public opinion about which forms of resistance are legitimate. He detailed how the discourse of violence has succeeded in delegitimizing liberation struggles around the world and how talk of violence is primarily concerned with means and not results. He pointed out that the institutionalized violence which has resulted from the attempts of Neo-Liberal organizations such as the World Bank and WTO to enforce their economic policies on the global South has killed more people (many more) than terrorism has. I suggest downloading the podcast or the video for this discussion; Dr. Alam's delivery was remarkable, charismatic, and engrossing. I was moved to by his book and have found it quite a good read.

The last panel, on Islam and Gender Politics, was definitely the most controversial. On the one hand, I agree with the speakers about the need for increasing participation by female 'Ulema in the process of developing Fiqh, especially where Women's issues are concerned. Misogynistic and gynophobic practices such as 'honor' killing need to be stopped and the judiciary made to prosecute the perpetrators. I disagree, however, with the attitude which pervaded the discussion. Overall, it was rather defeatist; it either assumed that the West is right about the 'oppression' of women in Islam or it tied concrete matters of Islamic Law, such as the laws of inheritance, into the specific society in which they were revealed. While context is incredibly important in matters of Fiqh, issues such as inheritance are not left solely to the discretion of the jurist; the core of these laws is enshrined in the Qur'an itself. Rather than abandon them because they cause us difficulties (or embarrass us in front of our Western neighbors), we must ponder the hikmah behind their institution and work to create a society where they can implemented justly. The laws were revealed in part to maintain economic balance in a society where the men were given the responsibility to care for three generations: their children, their unmarried female siblings in the absence of parents, and their parents in old age. Women are absolved of these financial responsibilities. There is a balance here. While men get gross more under this system, they also have many others who have share in their wealth; a women's property is hers and hers alone: it is not required that she spend it on anyone, not even her children. This is not simply an archaic social system; there is a wisdom behind it. This system allows for bringing up of the next generation and for the care of the preceding one on the basis of natural ties of affection and of an Islamic sense of duty to one's Creator. The drive for filthy lucre which dominates Western thought on these matters and which has created a generation eager to dump their parents in 'retirement' homes and their children into the arms of the state and the television is altogether absent. It also recognizes the value of women's work in the home, a value which cannot be reduced to a dollar value. They are therefore free to keep what property they have earned (and to earn more at her discretion) without being burdened with additional responsibilities beyond those of caring for her children (Housework such as cooking and cleaning is, from what I have read, actually the husband's responsibility).

This can be usefully contrasted with the position of women in the west, where until recently a wife became subsumed into the legal entity of her husband, where her property became his property, and where the husband felt entitled to extract as much work from her as he could get. With the onset of the industrial revolution women were, in addition to the indignities already mentioned, forced to deal with new challenges: in addition to what was demanded from them in the home they were forced by the poverty created by capitalism to work in the factories in horrendous conditions, subject to the perverted desires of their male supervisors and bosses who wielded near total control over them. The liberation of women has very much been the liberation of women to work, to add to the value of accumulating capital. Women are the oppressed of the oppressed, forced to slave under tyrants in both the factory and the home, adding value to capital in one and rearing the next brood of workers in the other. Even the increasing penetration of women into managerial positions has an economic underpinning; who better to complete the exploitation of women but women? Who knows better how to most thoroughly and efficiently derive the maximum economic benefit from having women in the labor force and consumer base?

Islam is founded on struggle. We should not simply accept existing political, social, and economic realities; we should endeavor to change them. The talk of rights is very often a guise for "that single, unconscionable freedom- Free Trade"(Marx); there are profound structural injustices and systems of exploitation waiting to be imposed upon Muslim women in the name of liberation. Conversely, much talk of establishing Islam reduces to a desire to institute a hand full of Hudd punishments and call it a day. Neither of these alternatives is acceptable; we must evolve our own discourse of liberty within community, guided by our understanding of the texts revealed by All-Mighty Allah (SWT) and founded upon a vision which embraces all aspects of personal and communal life: familial, social, cultural, political, and economic. This latter part has been horribly neglected; we hear right and left calls for establishing Islam as a social order but very little is done to establish this order on a solid, halal economic foundation. What good is it to on occasion stone or flog someone in the interests of promoting public order if that very order is established on exploitative and unjust economic practices and institutions? How can you establish a halal superstructure on a haram economic base? Until these economic issues are resolved, and they will only be resolved through great thought and struggle, any attempt to establish Islam culturally or socially will fail. Attempts at political reform or revolution will be mere window dressing if the economic base isn't remade according "Islamic concepts of 'adl and Ihsan"(Dr. Alam). I pray that Allah (SWT) grants this generation the capacity to succeed at this economic refoundation which the Ummah so desperately needs. Ameen.

Labels: ,

Washington College of Law Conference on Islamic Law in the West

I attended this conference last weekend and it was quite an experience. You can find a webcast here (video) and here (audio). Inshaa'Allah, I'll write more later.

Labels: ,

Thursday, February 01, 2007

Islam and Whiteness

"Once we realize that we have a common enemy, then we unite- on the basis of what we have in common. And what we have foremost in common is that enemy- the white man."
-Al-Hajj Malik Ash-Shabaz

Brother Malik ash-Shabaz (Malcom X) said these words at the tail end of his association with the Nation of Islam, but I don't think they can be dismissed as Black nationalist propaganda. Throughout his life, brother Malcom was intelligent, informed, and perceptive; he didn't magically gain these qualities in the last year of his life. So it behooves us as Muslims to consider these words. He ties in what he is saying (I am quoting from his Message to the Grass Roots) with the experience of the Bandung conference; I think this is key, because this conference had attendees from all over Asia and Africa. As he says, "the number one thing that was not allowed to attend the Bandung conference was the white man," so that the people could talk freely. He tells us that "once they kept him out, they found that they could get together." And they found out that when they looked at their various oppressors "the one thing that all of them had in common- they were all from Europe, they were all Europeans, blond, blue-eyed and white skins."

But surely there were people who were fair in skin and hair and eye at Bandung? After all it was organized by, among others, Pakistan, India, and Egypt, and was attended by representatives of peoples from throughout Asia and Africa. So the question is: Is it physical features and these alone which make one White or is Whiteness a social structure and a mentality which it is possible to opt out of and remove from one's self? This suggests the further question of whether one can be White and Muslim; Islam is opposed to all forms of jahiliyya and in the modern world there are few things more jahil than the notion of whiteness, of the superiority of the fair skinned people and the ideology and social system which supports White priviledge. It is quite clear from the authentic sources in Islam that the deen which Allah (SWT) has revealed to us through the Messenger (SAW) is for all mankind, of whatever geographic or ethnic origin and of whatever skin tone.

So there must be a way of opting out of Whiteness. This way can be found in the Sunnah of Rasulullah (SAW); by adopting his manners of dealing with other people, his pattern of dress, in short, the way of life which was revealed through him, Muslims can break the pattern of White supremacy which gags the social life not only of this nation but of the world. It uplifts the oppressed and rehabilitates the oppressor, socializing them to one another in the best possible away and uniting them in one common brotherhood. Practically, by wearing a Sunnah beard and observing the Hijab, by imitating the Messenger (SAW) in his manner of dress (such as the Kamees, the Thowb, and the Imamah) and by, if need be, changing one's name, a brother or sister of European origin can begin to break the back of the White priviledge which they have been given and can finally begin to understand something of the oppression under which our African, Middle Eastern, and South Asian brothers and sisters live. For this reason, I think it is advisable for european converts to marry outside of their ethnicity so as to avoid the formation of a new 'White' elite within the Muslim community living outside of the historic boundaries of Dar al-Islam. I think it is especially important for euro-american converts to follow the lead of our African-American brothers and sisters because they, more than any other group, are the indigenous Muslim community in this country and because they, more than any other group, have the experience to deal Islamically with the challenges which America poses for us. In addition this will be a necessary corrective to the unjust pattern of African innovation and euro-american co-optation which can so readily seen in the social history of the United States. The question that remains to be answered, as brother Malcom observed, is whether there are white people that want to be Muslim.

Labels:

Tuesday, January 30, 2007

Questions for Traditionalists

Check here for an interesting post.

This has lead me to the following musings.
How much of the traditionalist movement is a strictly a middle-class phenomenon? I know that Tareeqah Tijaniyyah is making inroads among the African community, but other than that organization what effect has there been among working class Muslims? I think there is an inherent bias in these salafi vs. traditionalist discussions, one which views things through the eyes of affluent, college educated, and internet connected immigrants and their children and convert-followers (especially among the whites) and not from the perspective of the oppressed black population and working class immigrant communities who, in shere numbers, make up the bulk of the Muslim community in this country. Even when one looks at Tablighi Jamaat, which is the closest thing there is to a traditionalist mass movement and which I respect very much for working so hard to spread the deen, one must ask how many of its members are elite professionals, how many affluent businessmen, and how many, once these first two categories are deducted, are working class people? This skewed class structure will introduce a systematic bias which will effect the formulation of goals, tactics, and criteria of success by the Islamic movement. It will also introduce economic, ethnic, racial, and social divisions which can be exploited to keep this movement fractured and weak. Instead of the oppressed working out their own liberation under the banner of Islam, we will have the affluent, with their own interests and biases skewing their vision, even if unintentionally, dictating what is and is not properly Islamic and thus either splintering the movement or moving it in directions which are ultimately futile. This is not to say that the wealthier brothers and sisters should be dismissed or ignored; but they do need to follow the lead of those who are on the front lines of the struggle, those who are experiencing the zulm of this jahil nation directly: these are the Black Muslims, the increasing number of Latino Muslims, and our working class immigrant brothers and sisters, all of whom are the first to be targetted by the oppressors.

There is also the issue of how to properly categorize some of the Urban
Masajid. Perhaps they are more political than Salafi; they are more flexible on certain fiqh issues due to the influence of the Salafi Dawah, but they are not tied with Saudi Arabia, are not rabidly anti-shi'ite, and are more concerned with community development and political solidarity than with extremely fine points of aqeedah. They pool their resources to help brothers and sisters in dire economic need, to provide social services, or to express solidarity with political prisoners instead of doing so to build the masjid a new parking lot. They are very critical of Zionism even though this is not the PC thing to do. They call attention to inability of this country to face its own racist and imperialist history, policies, and mentality, even though this may turn off some potential white converts. They are willing, in short, to speak the truth even when doing so will not gain them friends among the kuffaar and will perhaps even irritate their more comfortable brothers and sisters. Changes in orientation among the upper economic strata of Muslims in America do not necessarily reflect a deep-seated change in the American Islamic community as a whole. They may simply be an example of a politically quietistic turn among the affluent Muslims (especially given that the change is more towards the Deobandi-Tablighi tradition) which reflects both their alienation from politics and their desire to keep a low profile. This represents a reality of Islam that goes beyond a simplistic Salafi vs. Traditionalist dichotomy.

Labels: , ,

Thursday, January 25, 2007

An Inspiring Quote from an Inspiring Man

"I am Salman, the son of Islam from the children of Adam."- Hazrat Salman Al-Farsi (RA)

This adequately sums up my feelings on the subject; Islam is the universal birth right of all humankind. By embracing it one can overcome the jahiliyyah of one's own past and of the past (and ongoing) actions of one's race, ethnicity, or tribe. It offers the conception of the Ummah to stand against all of the petty idols of ethnocentric nationalism and of the unitary, homogenous nation-state. It offers the prospect of liberty from the tyranny of men through obedience to Allah and asserts the true rights which human beings have over one another. Finally, it offers the only real hope for developing a global civilization capable of mastering the challenges which modernity has thrust upon us: wars on a scale hitherto unimaginable, the increasing capacity for surveilance, manipulation, and enslavement which new technologies and techniques offer to governments, the prospect of an ecological catastrophy unique in human history, and, at the root of it all, a crisis of meaning which locks each individual into a near impenetrable shell of indifference and despair. May Allah bless humanity with a revivified Islam and may He cause it to spread across the surface of this earth, like a life-giving shower from the Heavens, from ocean to ocean and pole to pole. Ameen.

Labels: