Tuesday, February 27, 2007

A Letter to the Retriever Weekly Regarding "The X-Ray Project"

Dear Retriever Weekly,

I am writing concerning the “X-Ray Project” which has recently been installed in the Commons at the University of Maryland Baltimore County. This work consists of x-rays of victims of suicide bombings taken from Israeli hospitals. While I do not believe in censorship and certainly reject violence against innocent civilians, I object to the content of this exhibit for several reasons. It is utterly devoid of context; it depicts the violence perpetrated by one side in a brutal conflict in total isolation from the ongoing brutalities of the Occupation of Palestinian land. The exhibit ignores the structural injustices and ongoing military actions against civilian targets which breed the types of violence it seeks to condemn. The result is an unbalanced caricature of the conflict, one which serves no higher function than that of partisan propaganda. Whatever high moral feeling is meant to be reflected in the exhibit is vitiated by its selective presentation. By valorizing the suffering of the Israelis exclusively it negates the suffering of the Palestinians. The result is a kind of censorship by omission.

In addition, given the recent Israeli act of aggression against Lebanon it is in extremely bad taste to focus on a hand full of Israeli victims of terror while ignoring the near total destruction by Israel of one of its neighbors. The military actions against Lebanon included the use of cluster bombs, a war crime, which generate carnage on a scale that the wielder of a ‘suicide belt’ could only dream of achieving. The Israeli bombardment of Lebanon frequently targeted areas which were well outside of Hizbullah’s area of influence and served no purpose other than to inspire terror in the civilian population and undermine Lebanon economically. A well known example of the latter is the bombing by the Israeli Defense Force of a Christian farm complex in the North of the country; this farm had won the contract, formerly held by an Israeli company, for providing food to UN Peacekeepers stationed in the south.

This exhibit has a broader context than that of the Israeli/Palestinian conflict. Viewed in the wider context of Post-Colonial studies, it serves to demonize the resistance of the poor and oppressed, often conducted using crude, homemade weaponry, while sanctioning the use of military violence by states. This leads to moral paradox of condemning, rightfully, the death of a handful of innocent civilians at the hand of a resistance fighter while glorying in the destruction of towns and cities full of innocent civilians via aerial bombardment, as was the case in Groznyy, Beirut, and Fallujah. The fact that, more often than not, the suicide terror condemned in the exhibit stems from military actions such as these has been completely disregarded. The fundamental moral flaw, which is the pretense that the modern nation-state has the moral authority to deal out death and destruction as it sees fit, is left unaddressed. The problem of terrorism will never be resolved until the structural injustices which breed it are corrected and the violent proclivities of the nation-state are curtailed. No solution is offered by this exhibit; its sole purpose is to demonize Palestinians so that when Americans hear of the violence directed against them they shrug it off as a just desert.For this reason, I have no choice but to condemn this exhibit as propaganda.

Finally, this exhibit is inherently racist because it exhibits the results of the actions of a handful of Palestinians without calling attention either to the depredations which the Palestinian people daily face as a result of a decades long military occupation or to the fact that is in reality only a handful of Palestinians that are reacting in this way. Imagine, if you will, someone creating an exhibit which consisted of pictures of the Watts Riots and the LA Riots; imagine if these pictures showed only African-Americans engaging in looting and burning and various acts of violence. Would such an exhibit not be racist by the very fact that it excludes the context of ongoing, violent, structural oppression that the African-American population has been forced to experience? Would not the protestations by the exhibit’s creator that she is simply being ‘anti-riot’ be seen for their mendacity? And would not her complaints that her critics are ‘apologists’ for rioting be seen as the worst type of ad hominem attack? For these reasons I cannot remain silent when this type of exhibit is presented for the perusal of the student body. Silence becomes even more unacceptable when the author of the exhibit stigmatizes her critics as apologists for terrorism. I hope that the Retriever will see fit to publish this letter either in the Letters section or as an Op-Ed as a welcome opposing view on this controversial installation.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, February 06, 2007

Thoughts on the Conference on Islamic Law in the West

On Friday and Saturday I attended a conference on Islamic Law and the West held at the Washington College of Law. The list of speakers included Dr.Umar Faruq Abdullah, Dr. Mohammad Fadel, and Dr. M. Shahid Alam. The introductory panel consisted of an interesting, if basic, introduction to the categories used in Islamic Law (Dr. Fadel), an analysis of Islamic Constitutionalism with reference to the ideas of Abdul-Karim Sourush (Intisar Rabb), and an account of the recent attempt to provide alternative, religiously based arbitration in Ontario (Jasmin Zine). Dr. Abdullah presented the keynote address on "Muslims in the Mainstream" where he recounted something of the history of Islam in America and suggested tipping points to increase our political capital and counteract mainstream media demonization of Islam and Muslims.

The next day saw a panel on Islam and Violence. I was captivated by the speech of Dr. Alam; he spoke a truth which needed to be proclaimed in an elite college like American University. His primary thesis was that the threat of terror has been greatly exaggerated in order to scare the American people into agreement with draconian government policies and to manipulate public opinion about which forms of resistance are legitimate. He detailed how the discourse of violence has succeeded in delegitimizing liberation struggles around the world and how talk of violence is primarily concerned with means and not results. He pointed out that the institutionalized violence which has resulted from the attempts of Neo-Liberal organizations such as the World Bank and WTO to enforce their economic policies on the global South has killed more people (many more) than terrorism has. I suggest downloading the podcast or the video for this discussion; Dr. Alam's delivery was remarkable, charismatic, and engrossing. I was moved to by his book and have found it quite a good read.

The last panel, on Islam and Gender Politics, was definitely the most controversial. On the one hand, I agree with the speakers about the need for increasing participation by female 'Ulema in the process of developing Fiqh, especially where Women's issues are concerned. Misogynistic and gynophobic practices such as 'honor' killing need to be stopped and the judiciary made to prosecute the perpetrators. I disagree, however, with the attitude which pervaded the discussion. Overall, it was rather defeatist; it either assumed that the West is right about the 'oppression' of women in Islam or it tied concrete matters of Islamic Law, such as the laws of inheritance, into the specific society in which they were revealed. While context is incredibly important in matters of Fiqh, issues such as inheritance are not left solely to the discretion of the jurist; the core of these laws is enshrined in the Qur'an itself. Rather than abandon them because they cause us difficulties (or embarrass us in front of our Western neighbors), we must ponder the hikmah behind their institution and work to create a society where they can implemented justly. The laws were revealed in part to maintain economic balance in a society where the men were given the responsibility to care for three generations: their children, their unmarried female siblings in the absence of parents, and their parents in old age. Women are absolved of these financial responsibilities. There is a balance here. While men get gross more under this system, they also have many others who have share in their wealth; a women's property is hers and hers alone: it is not required that she spend it on anyone, not even her children. This is not simply an archaic social system; there is a wisdom behind it. This system allows for bringing up of the next generation and for the care of the preceding one on the basis of natural ties of affection and of an Islamic sense of duty to one's Creator. The drive for filthy lucre which dominates Western thought on these matters and which has created a generation eager to dump their parents in 'retirement' homes and their children into the arms of the state and the television is altogether absent. It also recognizes the value of women's work in the home, a value which cannot be reduced to a dollar value. They are therefore free to keep what property they have earned (and to earn more at her discretion) without being burdened with additional responsibilities beyond those of caring for her children (Housework such as cooking and cleaning is, from what I have read, actually the husband's responsibility).

This can be usefully contrasted with the position of women in the west, where until recently a wife became subsumed into the legal entity of her husband, where her property became his property, and where the husband felt entitled to extract as much work from her as he could get. With the onset of the industrial revolution women were, in addition to the indignities already mentioned, forced to deal with new challenges: in addition to what was demanded from them in the home they were forced by the poverty created by capitalism to work in the factories in horrendous conditions, subject to the perverted desires of their male supervisors and bosses who wielded near total control over them. The liberation of women has very much been the liberation of women to work, to add to the value of accumulating capital. Women are the oppressed of the oppressed, forced to slave under tyrants in both the factory and the home, adding value to capital in one and rearing the next brood of workers in the other. Even the increasing penetration of women into managerial positions has an economic underpinning; who better to complete the exploitation of women but women? Who knows better how to most thoroughly and efficiently derive the maximum economic benefit from having women in the labor force and consumer base?

Islam is founded on struggle. We should not simply accept existing political, social, and economic realities; we should endeavor to change them. The talk of rights is very often a guise for "that single, unconscionable freedom- Free Trade"(Marx); there are profound structural injustices and systems of exploitation waiting to be imposed upon Muslim women in the name of liberation. Conversely, much talk of establishing Islam reduces to a desire to institute a hand full of Hudd punishments and call it a day. Neither of these alternatives is acceptable; we must evolve our own discourse of liberty within community, guided by our understanding of the texts revealed by All-Mighty Allah (SWT) and founded upon a vision which embraces all aspects of personal and communal life: familial, social, cultural, political, and economic. This latter part has been horribly neglected; we hear right and left calls for establishing Islam as a social order but very little is done to establish this order on a solid, halal economic foundation. What good is it to on occasion stone or flog someone in the interests of promoting public order if that very order is established on exploitative and unjust economic practices and institutions? How can you establish a halal superstructure on a haram economic base? Until these economic issues are resolved, and they will only be resolved through great thought and struggle, any attempt to establish Islam culturally or socially will fail. Attempts at political reform or revolution will be mere window dressing if the economic base isn't remade according "Islamic concepts of 'adl and Ihsan"(Dr. Alam). I pray that Allah (SWT) grants this generation the capacity to succeed at this economic refoundation which the Ummah so desperately needs. Ameen.

Labels: ,

Washington College of Law Conference on Islamic Law in the West

I attended this conference last weekend and it was quite an experience. You can find a webcast here (video) and here (audio). Inshaa'Allah, I'll write more later.

Labels: ,

Monday, January 22, 2007

Islam Awareness Week at George Washington University

Begin Quote:

Come to as many events as you can!

Invite others and spread the word!

All events are free and open to the public.

ISLAM AWARENESS WEEK

Friday, January 26
• JUM'AH: "ISLAMIC ROOTS IN AMERICA"
Speaker: IMAM JOHARI
1:15pm, MC Continental Ballroom
[Chair of Government Relations for the Muslim Alliance in north America, President of the Muslim Society of Washington]

• EID AL-ADHA DINNER
"Hajj Pilgrimage: Uniting the Essence of a People"
6:30pm, MC Continental Ballroom
Speaker: IMAM MAGID
[Imam of ADAMS Center, Vice President of Islamic Society of North America (ISNA)]
Also Featuring Photo Exhibit by AASIL AHMAD

Saturday, January 27
• BOWLING FOR A CAUSE
IINTERFAITH Community Service
5pm, MC Hippodrome
Suggested Donation: 3 Canned Goods/Clothing for donation to Miriam's Kitchen

Sunday, January 28
• ISLAM AND BLACK AMERICA
2pm, MC Amphitheatre
Speaker: DR. SHERMAN JACKSON
[Professor of Arabic and Islamic Studies, Visiting Professor of Law, and Professor of Afro-American Studies at the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor]
Co Sponsored By NAACP

Monday, January 29
• AN IN DEPTH LOOK: BAN ON THE BURQA
7pm, MC Continental Ballroom
Speaker: MERVE KAVAKCI
[Professor at the Elliott School of International Affairs, In 1999, Kavakci ran for Parliament and was elected to the Turkish Grand National Assembly. However, she was prevented from swearing-in due to her headscarf. She is one of Turkey's pioneers in the women's political movement in the early 1990s.]
Co Sponsored By Islamic Alliance for Justice

Tuesday, January 30
• ART EXHIBIT
"Reflections of Identity"
11am-5pm, MC Great Hall

• LOYALTY TO GOD AND COUNTRY: MORAL OBLIGATIONS OF CITIZENSHIP
7pm, Continental Ballroom
Speaker: DR. LOUAY SAFI
[VP of the Association of Muslim Social Scientists, President of the Center for Balanced Development, Founding Member and Director of the Center for the Study of Islam and Democracy]
Co Sponsored By GW Democrats

Wednesday, January 31
• The Spiritual Expression of Arabic Calligraphy
1pm-4pm, MC 301
LECTURE AND CALLIGRAPHY WORKSHOP

• ESPIONAGE AT GUANTANAMO?
7pm, Grand Ballroom
Speaker: FR. CHAPLAIN JAMES YEE
[After being offically recognized twice for outstanding performance as a Guantanamo chaplain, Ch. Yee was arrested and imprisoned in an Naval brig for 76 days while being falsely accused of spying and espioage. Chaplain Yee's gripping account of his Guantanamo experience has been published and is entitled For God And Country: Faith and Patriotism Under Fire]
Co Sponsored By College Democrats, Asian Student Alliance, Sigur Center for Asian Studies (Elliott School of International Affairs)

Thursday, February 1
• MOVIE SCREENING: Islam Empire of Faith
11am and 2pm showings, MC 101

• MUHAMMAD AND THE FULFILLMENT OF THE BIBLICAL PROPHECY
7pm, MC Amphitheatre
Speaker: HISHAM MAHMOUD
[Professor of Advanced Arabic Studies at Princeton U and Ph.D. candidate in Islamic Studies at UCLA]

Friday, February 2
• COFFEE NIGHT
7pm, MC Continental Ballroom
Featuring Comedian MO AMER
ALLAH MADE ME FUNNY TOUR
------------------------------------------


Other Cosponsors for the week include Multicultural Student Services Center (MSSC), GW Dining Services Commisson, Colonial Nightcap, and Arab Student Association

End Quote

Labels:

Friday, January 19, 2007

Islamic Law in the West: Theory, Doctrine, and Practice

A conference on Islamic Law is being held at American University on Friday, February 2nd and Saturday February 3rd. Dr. 'Umar Faruq 'Abdullah and Dr. Azizah al-Hibri are scheduled to speak. It looks to be very educational and inshaa'Allah, I will be attending.

Labels: